Triple Bottom Line Cost-Benefit Analysis,Economic Impact Analysis,Geospatial Analysis

Biosolids Facility Triple Bottom Line Analysis


For decades, the Germantown and Salemtown neighborhoods in Nashville suffered from persistent challenges associated with sewage waste management—heavy truck traffic, pervasive odors, and significant community disruption. Nashville Metro Water Services responded with a bold $136 million investment in a cutting-edge Biosolids Facility that would fundamentally reimagine urban waste processing.

Prior to this innovative facility, raw sewage sludge was transported long distances, often facing disposal challenges that resulted in backups, odors, and increased municipal liability. Due to the facility’s decision to invest upfront in a better design, the long-term economic, social, and environmental benefits will prove transformative.

Overview

Wilmot conducted a Triple Bottom Line analysis to evaluate the impact of the Biosolids Facility, revealing a remarkable $493 million in total benefits. Our team's assessment went beyond traditional infrastructure evaluation, demonstrating the project's multifaceted value.

Key benefits identified included:

  • Environmental Improvements

    • Significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions

    • Mitigation of criteria air pollutants

    • Reduction of nitrogen runoff

    • Potential for future biogas reuse

  • Economic Advantages

    • Substantial operations and maintenance savings

    • Sludge disposal cost reductions

    • Revenue generation from biosolid pellet production

    • Savings to the agricultural industry

    • Increased property values

    • Avoided legal liabilities

The facility now processes sewage sludge into fertilizer pellets, creating a valuable soil amendment used in agriculture, erosion control, and landscaping. By transforming a problematic waste stream into a resource, Nashville demonstrated how innovative infrastructure can simultaneously address environmental, economic, and community challenges.

Wilmot’s Role

  • $493M Triple Bottom Line benefits over 20 years

  • Benefit-cost ratio of 1.77

Results

Location

Nashville, TN

Markets

Municipal

Water/Wastewater

Services

Triple Bottom Line Cost Benefit Analysis

Economic Impact Analysis

Geospatial Analysis

What is Wilmot’s Triple Bottom Line analysis?

A full-cost accounting of environmental, social, and economic impacts, providing a dollar value cost or benefit for each aspect your project is considering.

Infographic highlighting benefits of Metro Water Services' Biosolids Facility, including $493M total benefits over 20 years, $96M increase in property value, 62% higher property value than Davidson County, and 24K households' natural gas needs met. Shows 112K trucks removed from roads, 5.4M gallons of diesel avoided, $116M saved in sludge hauling, sludge equivalent to 455 miles diverted from landfill, 340K tons of pellets replacing chemical fertilizer, $40M in benefits, 234 tons less nitrogen runoff, and $4M in pellet sales revenue.